Native Navigation

Page Header

Nutrition & Training Tips

Friday, January 19, 2018

Understanding Bird Scent -- Part 1: The Bird

In his book Best Way To Train Your Gun Dog, Hall of Fame Trainer Delmar Smith said:  No one’s ever understood one thing about scent.”  Add this:  Odor chemistry is complex and still poorly understood. (The Science of Smell, Iowa State University May 2004). Now we can understand why few, if any, have dared enter this research field of bird scent and pointing dogs.

All bird dog owners have witnessed it; one day your dog is pointing birds at 30 yards and the next day he can’t find a ham sandwich lying in front of his nose.  This conundrum has challenged me for years to research and understand bird scent.  Bird scent is the common denominator in all bird dog work but is the least studied and written about.  During this past fall hunting season, I decided to spend time doing more research on bird scent.

This article is the first of three on the subject of bird scent.  In this article we’ll discuss how bird scent is created, in the second article, we’ll discuss the diffusion and travel of bird scent and, finally, the third article we’ll discuss the receptor of the scent…the dog’s nose.  Let’s get started. 

We’ll begin with a scientific description of scent.  Scent is created by a concentration of volatilized chemical compounds that have the ability to vaporize.  That vaporization is then dispersed into the atmosphere which creates a scent cloud and then identified by a dog’s sense of olfaction.  That’s a simplified explanation.

Okay, we have a simplified explanation; however, what creates the volatilized chemical compound?  Research indicates that most of those compounds are created from bacteria. Since bacteria are the catalyst for creating scent, let’s take a deeper look at this invisible factor.  Whether it’s a bird, dog or human, warm living bodies are covered with bacteria.  The human scalp alone has 1.46 million bacteria per square centimeter. Birds are covered with bacteria….both internally and externally. Birds have a population of bacteria known as ‘normal microbial flora’ which colonizes the skin and mucous membranes of the respiratory and gastrointestinal tract.  These bacteria are not disease causing and are referred to as ‘nonpathogenic’.  (Normal & Abnormal Bacterial Organisms of Birds by Linda Pesek, DVM).  As we search for the sources of scent from birds, we should keep in mind that bacteria will interact with both living and dead matter to create scent.  The bacteria eat the matter, extract nutrients for themselves and disburse their waste which vaporizes.  That process, the vaporization and dispersion of the volatilized compounds creates a scent cloud.

Okay, we have the scientific definition as a foundation; now let’s visit the practical side of bird scent…just what are all these little bacteria, in and outside of a bird, munching on?

I stumbled with this question during my early research.  Bird dog folks I spoke with said it was dandruff type shedding on the bird, one said it was the bird’s droppings and another said it was simply sweat (birds don’t sweat) and yet another said it was oil created by the feathers; however, feathers are dead and not capable of producing oil. It was obvious to me that I needed much more research.

Beginning with a simple internet search of ornithology, I contacted the Cornell University Department of Ornithology.  They provided me with a scent track that included books, research papers and noted scholars. My gratitude to Cornell University.

There are four sources of scent dispersed from our popular gamebirds.  Each source initially disperses its own vapor scent cloud (often referred to as a scent cone).

The first source, and the one your author feels has the greatest impact, is the uropygial gland. Here is a quote from a paper published by Dr. Rick Axelson (DVM) titled Preening or Uropygial Gland in Birds.  December 12, 2008. 

It (uropygial gland) secretes a thick, transparent, complex oil consisting primarily of diester waxes (uropygiols), fats and fatty acids.  The gland is located at the base of the tail, on the lower back, just in from of the tail feathers.  This area is generally featherless except for a tuft of down at the tip called uropygial wick.  The gland is bilobed, or has two symmetric parts.  The oil from each lobe of the gland is secreted through small papilla (nipple-like projection).  It performs many functions in the bird including water proofing, and keeping the skin, feathers and bill supple.  During preening, a bird transfers this oil to its feathers by rubbing its head and beak against the oil gland and then spreading the oil over the feathers on the rest of the body.

The uropygial gland wick is always there.  It’s a constant that provides scent at all times. Through preening, it also affects the second and third vapor scent clouds; which increases its importance.  Bacteria love oil…remember that bacteria was used to help clean-up the Gulf oil spill.

The second vapor scent cloud is a cocktail mix of several ingredients. All these ingredients interact with bacteria to create a scent cloud. One ingredient in this scent cloud are rafts of dead skin that are continuously shed by a bird.  There is minor disagreement amongst researchers regarding whether the skin sheds become scent creating vapor or are they simply a “raft” that carries other volatilized compounds airborne.  After studying many papers, your author feels that they are both. The evidence is very strong that they do serve as a raft (small air ship) which carries bacteria (scent)  into the atmosphere.  Another ingredient joining this cocktail are the small segments of the capsule that surrounds new feather growth.  As the feather grows, the capsule breaks apart and mixes with the wax and oil distributed by the uropygial gland.  And, of course, many of our game birds enjoy a dust bath.  Add dust to the cocktail.  And finally, if the bird is a ground rooster, then there is a good chance that there is residual scent, on the birds bottom, from bird droppings.   

The third vapor scent cloud is from the ground.  This is the scent cloud that most favors the tracking dog.  This scent cloud is also a cocktail mix.  It would include bird droppings, a mixture of skin cells, feather capsule pieces, dust, bacteria and crushed vegetation.  Ground bacteria immediately attack even the most microscopic piece of damaged vegetation from a walking or running bird.  Remember that uropygial gland?  Those skin cells, feather capsule pieces and dust were all rolled around in the uropygial gland wax and oils which were distributed by the bird through preening. As the bird moves, the motion (imagine a flour sifter) shakes many of  these particles loose and they fall to the ground.  Also, the running bird rubs against foliage, branches, etc. and leaves preening oil from the feathers.

And, here is the fourth scent vapor cloud…bird breath.  Dr. Dale Rollins, Executive Director of the Rolling Plains Quail Research Ranch in Texas is a strong believer in the bird’s respiratory system creating scent.  Dr. Rollins told me that his pointing dogs have never pointed a dead bird (no breath).  They point healthy birds and wounded birds but never a dead bird.  This makes sense…we all learned at an early age to use a mouth wash before a date.  Bacteria in the mouth creates scent. In paragraph five (above) we quote Linda Peek stating that bacteria is in the respiratory tract. Birds breathe through both their mouth and nostrils. Dr. Rollins asked me to mention that his conclusion is based on observation; not from scientific research.

A wild card in this subject of bird scent is pheromones.  There are both sex pheromones and defensive pheromones.  The sex pheromone is believed to identify the bird’s species, sex, age and social dominance.  Defensive pheromones are released when a bird is stressed; being pinned by a pointing dog would be a good example.  For birds, most research I could locate indicates pheromones are released by that reliable uropygial gland; however, it could also include the respiratory system…maybe both.

Regarding the four vapor scent clouds, shortly after dispersal, they all interact and become a potpourri of scent.  With all that amount of scent in the air, you may now ask “how could my dog miss that melange of scent”?   We’ll answer that question in the next edition of this series on scent.  We’ll cover all the atmospheric conditions that are known to affect scent dispersal.


Paul Fuller is a life-long sportsman.  He’s been an outdoor writer since 1971. He’s the host and producer of the award winning Bird Dogs Afield TV show(www.birddogsafield.com) and produced the epic video Grouse, Guns & Dogs. Paul shot over his first German shorthaired pointer in 1961. Paul may be reached at paul@birddogsafield.com


Literature Cited 
Axelson, Rick DVM, December 12, 2008, Preening or Uropygial Gland in Birds, Care & Wellness
Iowa State University, May 2004, The Science of Smell Part 2: Odor Chemistry (Yahoo Search)
Pesek, Linda DVM, July 1999, Normal & Abnormal Bacterial Organisms

Copyright 2017, Paul Fuller.


Wednesday, April 12, 2017

Generalize Your Training

Wow-- it seems everywhere I go, folks have puppies! And, they’re anxious for training advice.  Here’s advice that every puppy owner can use.  It’s about making your training more widely applicable.  In the gun dog training business, this is often referred to as generalizing commands and instruction. 

One example would be the use of a training table to teach the “whoa” command.  The training table is an excellent tool.  The primary purpose is to save your back from too much bending and have easy access to your pup when correction is needed. The same training could be done on the ground but with more effort. 

After only two or three sessions on the table, the pup will begin to understand what you’re asking him to do.  After five or six sessions, that pup will begin to look pretty good.  You’ll say, “Hey, that wasn’t as hard as I thought.”  Well, you’re only kidding yourself.  Put the pup on the ground, off lead, and allow it to run freely.  Then say “whoa”.  What happened?  Most likely the pup totally ignored you.  Why, because he was only taught to whoa on the training table. 

That doesn’t mean that your work on the training table was without value.  You have to plant the seed somewhere and the training table is an easy place to begin the effort.  And, you’ll want to make sure that they fully understand the command before you begin making the pup compliant in different locations.  If fully compliant on the training table, generalizing to new locations will be much easier.  After the whoa command is fully understood by your pup around the yard, you then need to move the training to the field.  The field is the ultimate testing grounds.  If you encounter non-compliance in the field, you need to go back and start over.  And that’s true with any command or desired action.

Another example of a lack of applicability I’ve witnessed is yard training on birds.  Several years ago I was asked to visit a new pointing dog owner and observe his pup.  He wanted to enter the pup in the AKC testing program.  In a very large yard, he had small clumps of shrubs, flowers, etc.  He had planted a quail in several of the clumps.  The pup was released about 30 feet from the first planted bird.  The pup then went very nicely from clump to clump and demonstrated a nice point at each clump.  As I watched, I felt the whole process appeared to be too structured and a robotic performance by the pup, which was about one year old as I recall.

I asked the pup owner if he had a field where we could run the same exercise.  The owner looked at me with a blank stare.  He then blinked and said “Well, I guess we could.”  We drove down the road to a field where he planted three birds.  He then returned to the truck for the pup.  He wanted to take the pup to the first bird on a check cord.  I suggested that he not do that.  In a test, the pup would have to locate the birds without being led to them.  He released the pup and it was a disaster.  The pup bumped two of the three birds and never showed any interest in the third bird. 

The issue, of course, is that the pup was trained to do something in a restricted manner.  It was obvious that this process was done over and over without any generalization.  Removed from the structured yard environment, the pup was lost.  After the owner of the pup saw a couple of nice finds and points in the yard, he should have immediately moved the training to a new location.  And, after a few successful exercises in the new location, move yet to another new location. 

Training must be widely applicable or it has very little value.  Allow that pup to have new, varied experiences in your training program to create a brag dog.


Paul Fuller is host of the Bird Dogs Afield TV program.  Paul’s website is www.birddogsafield.com.

Sunday, January 1, 2017

How Good is Your Bird Dog?

How good is your pointing grouse dog?  Fair? Good?  Outstanding?  What is the standard you use to judge your dog?  Your author has had the good fortune to watch and shoot over many pointing breed grouse dogs.  Those include English setter, English pointer, German shorthaired pointer, pointing griffon, Brittany and many more.  The training of these dogs has been from minimal to the very best field trial dogs. 

Now let’s back-up perhaps 150 years.  In the 1800s, outdoor and gun dog writers classified the ruffed grouse as unfit for sporting purposes.  The bird’s desire to quickly flush made it unfit for pointing dogs.  Course untrained dogs were used by the market shooters but that was the limit of grouse shooting with dogs.  It wasn’t until some of the more trained dogs from the South made their way North before it was discovered that pointing dogs could be trained to properly handle the elusive ruffed grouse.

Today, as mentioned above, there are many pointing breeds capable of handling the King of Gamebirds.  Now, let’s get back to the opening sentence:  How good is your pointing dog on grouse? Most gun dog owners overrate their dog(s).  They want so badly to have a good grouse dog that they make believe that their dog is good.  I occasionally find myself in that group.  One of my shorthairs will make a mess of a grouse find and I’ll make an excuse for him.  The really good grouse dogs rarely make a mistake…and I truly mean the really good dogs. 

Here’s an example of someone who thought he had a really good dog.  Several years ago, I received an email asking me if I had knowledge of a Brittany kennel in Maine.  The man wanted to buy a Brittany puppy from this kennel.  I called the kennel and asked if their dam was a hunter.  The woman said that they didn’t hunt but I could call a buyer of one of their pups who is an avid upland hunter.  I called the man who bought a pup three years earlier from this kennel.  He said he had the best grouse dog in the State of Maine.  He invited me to come watch his dog work. That was fine because I was traveling his way the following week.  If I recall, it was the second week in September.  The dog owner had a very nice grouse covert that he promised would hold grouse.  And it did.  The dog had three grouse finds in about one hour.  All three grouse were runners and flushed way ahead of the dog and the dog owner.  After each flush, the dog owner would say “Wasn’t that great dog work?”  And, when we finished, he said:  “Have you ever seen anything that good?”   Well, I was very diplomatic and told him he had a “nice” dog and I appreciated his time.  However, that was lousy dog work. 

The bottom line, the absolute standard, for outstanding pointing dog work on ruffed grouse is whether the bird is there when you, the hunter, gets to the dog.  Is the bird within range for a shot?  The number of faraway flushes made in front of the dog has no value to the hunter.   

Having established a standard for outstanding grouse work, how many dogs can actually pin every grouse find and have it there when you, the hunter, arrives?  Very few.  In fact, I’ve only seen one.  Her name was Long Gone Madison, an English setter, and she was considered amongst the top five grouse dogs ever.  I watched her pin nine grouse in one hour.


Now we know what the very best can do.  How about your dog?  If your dog can pin 50% of their grouse finds, then you have a very good grouse dog.  More than 50%, you have a true “brag dog” that can run with the best.  Pinning less than 50% will still give you a good dog, however, if it’s say one in ten, then your dog is simply a weekend hunter and you’re both out just for fun.  And, just being out for a fun day with your best friend is a beautiful thing. 


Paul Fuller is host of the Bird Dogs Afield TV program.  Paul’s website is www.birddogsafield.com.